One of my pet peeves is reading blog posts and forum comments comparing ruggedized, semi-rugged, and fully rugged laptops and notebooks to popular consumer models and then concluding that the value ratio is out of whack somehow, or that the pricing is way out of line. This post is a paraphrase to a comment I left on just such a blog post from a supposed tech blog. I just ask that people do their homework before they write comparative product reviews. We all know what opinions resemble.
This post is not intended to offend your sensibilities, nor disregard personal opinions. Those involved in the ruggedized, semi-rugged, and fully rugged niche, understand that a rugged laptop involves more than a ”hard plastic case and a spill proof keyboard membrane”. This is to note and to share some relevant information. It also is true that marketing departments can seemingly be awol when they name new rugged laptop products.
Mil-Std 810F is a Department of Defense Test Method Standard that establishes uniform environmental test methods for determining the resistance of materials to the effects of natural and induced environments peculiar to military operations. This is the default standard the industry is currently using as the measure for rugged laptops.
”It focuses on the process of tailoring materiel design and test criteria to the specific environmental conditions a materiel item is likely to encounter during its service life.”
http://www.dtc.army.mil/navigator/
The Environments are 1. Altitude 2. Temperature 3. Rain and Dust 4. Humidity. 5. Cold Storage 6. Vibration 7. Shock. 8. Drop
Mil-Std 810F test methods do not require the use of specific materials, hardware, nor specific manufacturing processes. An 810F certified device is not the result of surrounding consumer electronics inside a heavy-duty enclosure such as ballistic plastic, although that could very well be a selected design material for testing and manufacture.
For this reason, the price points usually demonstrated in the side-by-side comparisons between popular consumer brand models that appear to be similarly equipped do not tend to be examples of particularly good, nor reliable analysis. You have to look under the hood, so to speak This should help answer the question of why rugged laptops seem to cost so much.
Businesses, public services, industry, the military, utilities, and other organizations that rely on the rugged portable category to perform in extreme conditions on a daily basis would have a hard time giving up this “rugged gear”.
Rugged Notebooks: Extreme Computers for Extreme Conditions™